• Home
• People
• Mark mcgwire vs

Mark mcgwire vs

Mark mcgwire vs. sammy sosa

During the 1998 baseball season, Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa have excited fans with the greatest home run race in the history of the game. By mid-September, both players surpassed Roger Maris's single season record of sixty-one homers, set back in 1961. Sosa and McGwire are both great players. However, McGwire has been getting much more media attention; partly because has led the race most of the season, but mainly because he has admitted to using a controversial drug called Androstenedione. Although reactions have varied from casual acceptance to utter disgust, many people have proposed that the record books contain an asterisk, cautioning that McGwire's record was the result of Androstenedione use. To verify the need for this asterisk, one must examine the significance of this drug, and compare McGwire with the other home run kings.
In any issue involving sport and drugs, the primary concern is whether or not use of such a drug is legal, according to the governing body of that sport. Fortunately for Mark McGwire, use of Androstenedione does not violate any rules of Major League Baseball. While critics such as Richard Griffin, Toronto Star Baseball Columnist, argue that Andro is a "testosterone-producing product that is banned in the NFL, Olympics, and NCAA," they fail to mention that neither the NHL nor the NBA has banned this over-the-counter product.
More relevant than the drug's legality is it's effect on McGwire's ability to hit home runs. "In 1987, his rookie year, McGwirehit 49 home runs" (Dimanno). In fact, if McGwire had not been injured so often throughout his career, Maris's record would have been surpassed several times already. After eleven years of learning how different opponents pitch, developing an effective swing, and working out in the gym, is it any wonder that McGwire has finally put together a strong, consistent season and will end up with close to seventy home runs? All the Androstenedione did was help McGwire's body recover from his workouts: an advantage that today's athletes have over their predecessors.
Placing an asterisk next to McGwire's record would indicate to people that the record is not legitimate because McGwire had a significant advantage over the likes of Babe Ruth and Roger Maris. Isn't it funny how history repeats itself? Back in 1961, Roger Maris's record had an asterisk placed beside it because he had hit 61 home runs in a 162 game season, while Ruth's record was set in a 154 game season. "Only in the last decade was that asterisk acknowledged to be unfair and an insult to Maris' memory � at long last it was officially removed from the record book" (Don't, Woolsey).
However, if MLB decides the McGwire record should include supplementary notes on the significant advantages that he had over Roger Maris, here is the warning they shall want to place in explanation of their asterisks: Please note that this record is semi-legitimate, as Mark McGwire has had several advantages over Roger Maris. 1) McGwire has used Creatine, an amino acid builder that was unavailable back in 1961; since Maris was unable to use Creatine to supplement his workouts, we must place asterisk number 1. 2) MLB would like to note that Mark McGwire has had the option of training all year round, a significant training advantage never made available to Roger Maris; thus, asterisk number 2. 3) It must be noted that McGwire's trainers have access to "sophisticated nutritional and training knowledge" (McGwire, Woolsey) that Maris never received; therefore, asterisk number 3. 4) Furthermore, Mr. McGwire has had the opportunity to study different pitchers by use of a new technology called videotapes; this unfair advantage forces the inclusion of another asterisk. 5) Oh! and Mark McGwire also used a second workout supplement called Androstenedione, which did not violate any rules of MLB.
As many advantages as Mark McGwire may have over the home run kings of the past, one constant remains: "simply putting the ball into play against big-league pitching remains the greatest challenge" (McGwire, Woolsey). So, how should his record look when it is placed in the record books? Impressive. Undisputed. A mark by which all other's shall be compared. Without an asterisk.